An employer assesses whether the training budget is being put to good use by looking at how it is utilised, employees’ experiences and how well it aligns with the organisation’s development needs. A budget is only put to good use when employees make informed choices that align with their talents, ambitions and future roles. Below, you can read how to assess this in practice.
What are the signs that the budget is not being used?
The clearest indication is when a large proportion of the development budget remains unused at the end of the year. Even if the same staff members consistently make use of the budget whilst others never do, or if applications mainly consist of one-off courses, the budget’s potential remains untapped.
Also, look out for clues in conversations. Staff who are unsure what they can use their personal development budget for often put off making a decision. If the topic of the career budget is completely absent from development discussions, staff often do not realise it exists. Unclear guidelines on what is and isn’t reimbursed also lead to reluctance.
Which figures really tell us anything about budget spending?
The most useful figures are the percentage of staff who use the budget, the distribution across departments and roles, and the type of expenditure. The total amount spent is of little significance, as it says nothing about who benefits or whether the investment meets the need.
To properly assess the training budget, you need to look at a combination of factors:
- Range: Which proportion of staff are making use of the budget, and which groups are lagging behind?
- Timing: Is the budget spread out over the year, or is it mainly used in the final months?
- Type of expenditure: Is it about training courses, assessments, coaching or career guidance?
- Conclusion: Are the chosen development paths also finalised and discussed with the line manager?
The figures show what is happening. The why You only really get to know them through conversations with your staff.
How do you ask staff about their experience?
It is best to ask staff about their experience in a face-to-face conversation or via a short, accessible questionnaire, preferably shortly after the completion of a development phase. Ask open-ended questions about what they gained from it, what they felt was still missing, and what previously prevented them from using the budget.
The development review is the natural setting for this. Questions that work well:
- What would you like to learn or discover in the coming years?
- What has stopped you from using your budget so far?
- Which stage of your development has helped you the most, and why?
- What do you need to be able to make a better choice?
Make it safe. If staff realise that their answers aren’t being used to assess them, but to improve the service, they’ll be much more open about what’s going on.
When is a purchase a really good choice?
A career path is well chosen when the employee can explain why this step aligns with their talents, ambitions and future prospects. An approved application is therefore not automatically a good choice. It is about the alignment between what someone wants, what someone is capable of and what their career requires.
At Nieuwkans, personal development begins with self-awareness, not with a training programme. Not every development need immediately calls for a course. Sometimes, career guidance or a conversation with a coach is more valuable first, so that the next step can be chosen consciously. A key question to ask to ensure your money is well spent:
- Does it align with the employee’s ambitions?
- Does it suit his or her natural talents and preferences?
- Does it contribute to a role or position that will be relevant over the next one to three years?
- Will there be a discussion afterwards about what the outcome was?
How do you align the budget with future staffing requirements?
You align the budget with future staffing requirements by identifying the skills the organisation will need in the coming years and the talents that are already in place. You then encourage development choices that bridge the two, whilst ensuring that employees retain control over their own development.
It starts with looking at skills rather than just qualifications and job titles. A great deal of talent is already present within the organisation, but it is not always visible. With a skills-based approach to strategic workforce planning – as we’ve developed it together with 3Wins in Skillscapers – you gain insight into existing skills and the roles you’ll need in the future. This isn’t advice on reorganisation, but a foundation for making better decisions, including regarding internal career progression. You can read more about our approach for organisations at sustainable employability for employers.
For staff, this means that the discussion about the development budget is not just about their current role, but also about what the organisation and the staff member will be able to offer each other in the future.
What do you do if staff fail to make full use of the budget?
If staff are not making full use of the budget, start by lowering the barriers: make it clear what is possible, discuss development on a regular basis and offer guidance on making a choice. Often, the cause is not a lack of interest, but uncertainty about the direction to take or confusion about the rules.
Practical steps that work:
- Communicate clearly: Please explain what the personal development budget can be used for, such as training courses, assessments or career guidance, depending on your agreements or collective labour agreement.
- Have the conversation early on: Discuss career development aspirations before staff become stuck in a rut or outgrow their role.
- Provide a starting point: Anyone who doesn’t know what they want needs, above all, self-awareness. Career guidance or an understanding of one’s natural talents can be a first step.
- Schedule some time for: Ensure that development is discussed in several meetings throughout the year, so that the budget is not only raised in December.
At BrainsFirst, we identify natural talents and cognitive behavioural preferences as a starting point for discussions with a coach. This helps employees who are unsure to make more informed choices about how they spend their budget. Whether a specific programme can be reimbursed from the development budget depends on the arrangements within your organisation or the relevant collective agreement.
Anyone evaluating the training budget therefore looks beyond the amount spent. It’s all about usage, experience, choices and the link to what the organisation and its staff will need in the future.
Does your organisation want to better align its development budget with the talents of its staff? Then take a look at what Nieuwkans does in the field of sustainable employability for employers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I go about reviewing the training budget if we’ve never looked at it systematically before?
Start with a baseline assessment: retrieve data from your HR system to find out how many staff members used the budget last year, how usage is distributed across departments and roles, and what the budget was spent on. Next, organise a series of brief interviews or a mini-survey with a sample of staff to find out why some people use the budget whilst others do not. This will give you an initial picture within a few weeks, on which you can base specific improvement measures.
How often should I review the use of the development budget?
A full review once a year is a good minimum, but you should also check the figures halfway through the year so that you can make timely adjustments if usage is lagging behind. It’s also wise to discuss development in several meetings throughout the year, so that the budget isn’t only brought up in December. This helps prevent a rush of last-minute requests at the end of the year.
What if some departments or job categories consistently make less use of the budget?
First investigate the cause before taking action: is it down to work pressure, a lack of time, unclear guidelines or a lack of attention from the line manager? In production or scheduling roles, practical obstacles often play a greater role than motivation. Tailor your communication and approach to each target group, for example by offering short, accessible programmes, time set aside during working hours, or extra guidance when making a choice.
How can I prevent staff from spending the budget solely on individual courses that aren’t relevant to their career?
Before submitting their application, ask staff to briefly explain how this move aligns with their talents, ambitions and future prospects, for example by referring to the four key questions in this article. In addition, offer an alternative starting point – such as a career guidance session, a talents analysis or a coaching session – for those who are not yet sure which direction they want to take. This ensures that the budget is a conscious choice rather than a knee-jerk reaction.
How can I ensure that managers conduct the discussion about the development budget effectively?
Provide managers with a simple framework for these discussions, featuring open-ended questions, such as what someone would like to learn in the coming years and what has held them back so far. Also explain what can and cannot be reimbursed, so that they do not send staff off on a wild goose chase. A short training session or peer review for managers on development reviews helps to ensure the discussion remains safe and focused on development rather than assessment.
How can I tell whether an expenditure has actually delivered any results?
At the end of each programme, arrange a brief evaluation meeting between the employee and their line manager to discuss what has been achieved, what has been learnt and how this is being put into practice. In the longer term, also look at indicators such as internal progression, job enlargement, engagement and absence or staff turnover figures. Bear in mind that the value of development is not always directly measurable, so always combine figures with the employee’s experience.
What should I do if the budget is consistently not being spent, despite good communication?
In that case, it makes sense to look at the underlying conditions: is there sufficient time and scope for development, do staff feel free to choose, and does the provision meet their needs? Consider using the budget more flexibly, for example for assessments, coaching or career guidance alongside traditional training programmes, within the framework of your agreements or collective labour agreement. If take-up remains low, discuss with staff whether the size and structure of the budget still meet their needs.