What do you need to find out before you go into the interview?
Before you have your meeting with HR, find out three things: what your personal development budget can be used for, how much the budget is, and what procedure your employer follows. This will prevent the meeting from getting bogged down in practical questions and ensure there is still time to focus on the substance.
Start with the source of your budget. This is usually set out in your collective agreement, employment contract or staff handbook, or on the intranet. Bear the following points in mind:
- Amount and term: What is your budget, and is there an expiry date, or can you carry it over to the following year? That varies depending on the employer and the collective agreement.
- Permitted expenditure: Does this cover only training programmes and courses, or does it also include assessments, career coaching and career guidance?
- Procedure: Do you need to ask for permission in advance, and who decides – HR or your line manager?
- Terms and conditions: Are there any arrangements regarding a refund if you leave within a certain period?
If you’re stuck, just ask HR a quick question. That will only help to focus your discussion afterwards. Exactly what can be reimbursed always depends on the arrangements with your employer or the relevant collective agreement.
How do you find out which stage of development is right for you?
You’ll discover which stage of development suits you best by first gaining self-insight: what do you want, what are you capable of, and which direction is realistic? Only then should you choose a course, training programme or coaching programme. A course is a possible next step, not an end in itself.
Many people start the other way round. They look for a course that sounds interesting and only consider later whether it fits in with their career. We prefer to do it the other way round. Not every development need immediately calls for a training course. Sometimes a chat with a coach, a skills assessment or career guidance is a better first step.
Here are a few questions to get you started:
- Which tasks give you energy and which ones drain your energy?
- Which skills are you still not making the most of?
- How will your role or field of work change over the next one to three years?
- Where do you see yourself working in a few years’ time, either within or outside your current organisation?
If you’d like some help with this, that’s fine. The Career Guidance Package helps you discover what your talents are and which career path suits you best. BrainsFirst identifies your natural talents and cognitive behavioural preferences, as a starting point for your discussion with a coach. It is not a definitive assessment of your potential, but a tool to help you steer your career more consciously.
How do you justify your career development aspirations to HR?
You can justify your career development request to HR by demonstrating what you want to learn, why now is the right time, and how it will benefit both you and the organisation. A specific request with a clear link to your work and the future of your team is more likely to be well received than a general desire to develop.
Build your argument in four steps:
- The starting point: What is your current situation, what challenges are you facing, and what are you hoping to achieve?
- The development stage: What exactly would you like to do – for example, career coaching, an assessment or a training course?
- The added value for the organisation: What skills will you bring back to your team, and how will this tie in with future roles or changes?
- The practical side: How much does it cost, how much time does it take, and does it fit within your development budget?
HR doesn’t just consider your wishes, but also what the organisation will need in the future. If you can explain how your development will contribute to internal career progression or to skills that are becoming increasingly important, you’ll make it easier for HR to say yes. That said, don’t expect approval to be a foregone conclusion. A well-reasoned case does, however, increase the likelihood of a constructive discussion.
What does a development review with HR actually involve?
A career development meeting with HR usually follows four steps: you explain your situation and career aspirations, HR asks probing questions, you discuss the options within your budget, and you conclude by agreeing on the next steps. Being well prepared makes the meeting a lot more relaxed.
This is what the conversation often goes like:
- Opening: Briefly explain where you’re at and what you’d like to discuss.
- Floor: HR will ask you about your motivation, your plans and how your career development fits in with your role and the organisation.
- Options: Together, you’ll look at the options, the rules governing the development budget and any alternatives.
- Conclusion: Please set out the next steps and who will take responsibility for what.
A few tips for yourself: stay curious rather than defensive, ask questions yourself, and make a note of the key points during the conversation. It’s best to discuss your development goals well before the budget needs to be spent. That way, you’ll have time to choose carefully and make any necessary adjustments.
What do you do if HR rejects your request for professional development?
If HR rejects your development request, first ask why, and then work together to explore alternatives. A rejection doesn’t have to be a definitive ‘no’. Often, it’s down to budgetary constraints, timing or a lack of clarity about the added value, and there’s usually something that can be done about it.
Here’s what you can do:
- Ask more: Was it the content, the costs, the timing or the regulations? Only once you know the reason can you do something about it.
- Please amend your proposal: Perhaps a smaller step, a different provider or a different time would be better.
- Refine your reasoning: Explain in more detail how your development aligns with the organisation’s needs.
- Ask about alternatives: Consider an in-house training course, a learning project, on-the-job coaching or a joint investment.
- Arrange a follow-up meeting: Give HR time to contribute their ideas and agree on a date to review the matter again.
Keep the discussion constructive and professional. That way, you’ll keep the lines of communication open, even for a subsequent round.
What arrangements do you set out following the meeting?
Following the development review, you should set out which development step you are going to take, the budget available for it, who will give approval, and the timeframe within which everything must be finalised. Written agreements prevent misunderstandings and give you certainty regarding your personal development budget.
Please ensure that at least the following is clear:
- the chosen development stage and the desired completion date;
- the approved amount and what is and is not covered by it;
- any conditions, such as reimbursement or working time you are allowed to use;
- the procedure for claiming expenses or issuing invoices;
- the moment when you sit down with HR or your line manager to reflect on what you’ve gained from the experience.
After the meeting, send a short email summarising the discussion and asking for confirmation. It takes five minutes and prevents any disputes later on. If you’re still unsure about the direction you want to take, we’d be happy to help you with career orientation, so that you can go into your next development review with greater self-awareness and a greater sense of control over your own career. Want to read more about taking control of your own career? Then take a look at our page on sustainable employability for employees.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I get started if my employer doesn’t have a fixed personal development budget?
Even without a fixed budget, you can discuss a development request. In that case, draw up a concise proposal setting out your development plan, the costs, the time commitment and the added value for the organisation, and ask HR what options are available. There is often scope for this through a team training budget, a collective agreement scheme or a joint investment by the employer and the employee.
When is the best time to request a development review with HR?
Ideally, schedule the meeting well in advance of the budget expiring or the budget round beginning, for example in the first or second quarter. It is also a good time to hold the meeting following a change of role, a reorganisation or a performance review. Send a brief email in advance setting out the subject, so that HR can prepare.
What if my career development goals do not directly align with my current role?
State this clearly and explain how this step will contribute to your career, for example through internal promotion or by developing new skills that the organisation will need in the future. Check whether partial reimbursement is available, or whether you can combine it with your own time or money. Also check your collective agreement or scheme to see whether the career budget can be used for purposes other than role-specific training.
Do I have to repay the cost of my training if I change jobs?
That depends on the terms set out in your employment contract, study costs clause or collective labour agreement. Often, a repayment scheme applies if you leave within a certain period after completing your studies, usually on a pro rata basis. Check this with HR in advance and make sure it’s set out in writing, so you don’t face any surprises.
How exactly should I prepare if I don’t yet know exactly what I want to develop?
Start by gaining some self-insight rather than looking for a course. Write down which tasks give you energy, which skills you aren’t using enough, and where you want to be in three years’ time. You could also bring this up in a conversation and ask HR whether career guidance, a talent assessment or coaching is possible within your budget.
How can I ensure that my development agreements don’t lose their impact after the meeting?
Send a brief summary by email within a few days and ask for confirmation. Make a note in your diary for a mid-term review and to look back on what the development step has achieved. Keep track of your own progress so that, at the next meeting, you can demonstrate specifically what you have learnt.
Can I involve my line manager in the meeting with HR?
Yes, that’s often a good idea, especially if your line manager will ultimately have to give their approval or cover your workload whilst you’re on the course. Discuss your plan with your line manager first and ask if they’re willing to support your proposal. A joint message makes it easier for HR to reach a decision.